Whos The Better Running Back? Gore Or Barber?

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.

Whos The Better RB?


  • Total voters
    53

phil

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
7,311
27
0
116
#44
if all 3 rbs were to keep the same pace for the next 5 years, ap would leave diarrhea stains all over barber and gore. he already did it in his rookie year.
 

Chree

Medicated
Dec 7, 2005
32,404
13,935
113
40
#45
Wrong! His name is already in the record books...

But Gore vs Barber is a good debate....
lol theres alot of 1 hit wonders in the record books....
Jeff Garcia put up some records over Young and Montana, is Garcia better?


if all 3 rbs were to keep the same pace for the next 5 years, ap would leave diarrhea stains all over barber and gore. he already did it in his rookie year.
Well thats the thing, you wont see for a few years.... he could turn out to be like kevan barlow, and never say never, cuz its very possible....
 

Palmer

RIP SouthernComfort
Apr 10, 2006
4,985
4,812
113
40
SEAHAWKS!!!
#47
Adrian Peterson>Ladainian Tomlinson>Marion Barber

Right now that's how I see the RB talent in the NFL. Yeah theirs like 6 players ranked higher then Barber right now but I feel that he has the O line and the toughness to be in the top 3. As long as he stays healthy that is.

I fully expect to get clowned on for it but that's just where I'm at.
 
Mar 18, 2006
819
259
0
42
#49
That is tough to say, Id say just based off who I would want on my team, Barber. He shows up every game, Gore is a gamebreaker, but he is inconsistent.
 
Mar 10, 2007
2,603
57
0
38
#50
lol theres alot of 1 hit wonders in the record books....
Jeff Garcia put up some records over Young and Montana, is Garcia better?




Well thats the thing, you wont see for a few years.... he could turn out to be like kevan barlow, and never say never, cuz its very possible....
Who's Kevan Barlow? :knockout::knockout::knockout: haha
 
Apr 5, 2005
4,269
1
0
43
#51
You should have started this POLL after the 08-09 season because Barber was not a starter last year. He has paid his due and is getting the opportunity to shine.

But I'ma go with Gore because he is more agile and more explosive in the open field and has homerun capabilities.

Barber is a power back that lacks the break away speed that Gore possesses.

This is a tough decision tho.
 

CZAR

Sicc OG
Aug 25, 2003
7,269
1,375
0
52
#52
Put what to rest????? Barber is better and I could careless what anyone else has to say!! I form my own opinions and barber shits on Gore!!! Nice poll by the way on a bay area site like fresh said!! hahahah!! Got Em!!!
 
Nov 7, 2006
7,383
36
0
40
#54
i voted barber cause i think he'll be alot better than gore since he got the full starting job but both are almost equally good so who cares? be happy u guys got elites on ur squad dammit lol
 

DUTCH-F.E

Super Moderator
Apr 25, 2002
7,029
8,094
113
44
WWW.myspace.com
#55
barber is a beast. he runs hard no doubt. and he also gets every carry inside the 10 yard line. period. so those 10 td's last year were the same as the raiders running back from 2-3 years ago. dude had less than 300 yards rushing but was like 4th in the afc in touchdowns. barber has zero lateral shakes and would rather run you over than make a move and get further. gore is a complete running back, with the ball in his hands and without.

barber has a probowl quarterback, t. owens and 1 hell of a offensive line.

gore has the niners.

you can vote how you choose to, but you are merely kidding yourself if you say barber is better than gore.

p.s.
if barber is sooooo good why did dallas draft a back up college running back in the first round? the niners might have drafted shitty but we sure didnt draft a running back.
 
Jul 8, 2007
2,671
1
0
37
#58
I have no way of knowing, he hasnt played a full game yet. Personally I dont want him as a full time back, Id rather have Felix Jones wear the defense out with his speed and have barber just run them over. or the other way around. Barber is fast but his not that fast.
 

Arson

Long live the KING!!!!
May 7, 2002
15,795
10,860
113
#59
I have no way of knowing, he hasnt played a full game yet. Personally I dont want him as a full time back, Id rather have Felix Jones wear the defense out with his speed and have barber just run them over. or the other way around. Barber is fast but his not that fast.
he cant be a full time back, he lacks the talent.
 

Arson

Long live the KING!!!!
May 7, 2002
15,795
10,860
113
#60
Put what to rest????? Barber is better and I could careless what anyone else has to say!! I form my own opinions and barber shits on Gore!!! Nice poll by the way on a bay area site like fresh said!! hahahah!! Got Em!!!
your like a parent who thinks there ugly ass kid is cute, good job.