LOL damn. Ok IF Davis was only 23 right now then yes, you take Davis, but Davis is far removed from 23 right now. He's a seasoned vet so if his numbers SHOULD be higher. It is EXTREMELY rare that a guy at 23 has those types of numbers. Its not stupid to compare age 23 stats because that should illustrate how comparable the two actually are. And even now, Davis is not all that far ahead of Roy.