Superbowl XLII....I mean XLVI: Giants vs Patriots
- Thread starter Defy
- Start date
lol at that stat being like 1% better. also i put up the more important stat for QB and that's the QB rating which equals in yards attempts and ints all together, and yeah brady's are better. and you watch colts superbowl run? peyton had 1 good game THATS IT. you keep showing your stupid so please keep replying. it's almost not fair debating with you haha
i'm sorry peyton played 3 more years then brady. i put brady's injury in to consideration and not peyton's when i said 4. what's reading have to do with any of this? i put stats up since you're dumbass was saying do the math so i did and it came up as brady being better. reason i think he's better is because he's done more as a QB than peyton with less weapons and he didnt do it in a dome.
i'm sorry peyton played 3 more years then brady. i put brady's injury in to consideration and not peyton's when i said 4. what's reading have to do with any of this? i put stats up since you're dumbass was saying do the math so i did and it came up as brady being better. reason i think he's better is because he's done more as a QB than peyton with less weapons and he didnt do it in a dome.
to be fair brady played most of his career in the era where you were able to be hit, but i agree with you 100% and i think Montana is G.O.A.T. I'm just saying if someone says Brady is better it isnt like it's crazy since he's had the better stats and he just might get 1 more ring before he retires. shit even Montana thinks he's the greatest to play it but i do not.
sorry for the triple post but i just keep seeing great quotes. and yes they are both great but i can't see in anyway how peyton can be better. i mean base it on stats or winning and brady got both over him. t-rip saying peyton was the coach is stupid. he just ran the hurryup to perfection (which brady does now) so it made him look like he was doing it all on his own.
he did though. these new QB rules started taking effect in like 07ish. but yeah montana played where you were completely able to murder a QB and get away with it, but brady wasnt brought up with these new rules like Rodgers will be. shit Rodgers is gonna demolish all records most likely with the way NFL is going.
blah blah blah, good luck in Brady getting damn near 15,000 yards in 3 seasons if Peyton never took another snap. I guess you also forget Brady inherited a playoffs caliber team and Peyton didnt but then again the Colts arent a playoff caliber team without Peyton and the Patriots are without Brady which was the whole point in the first place. Total stats is all that matter and besides ints and maybe qb rating Peyton will be higher in every category when its all said and done
inherited a playoff team? please dont make remarks about shit you don't know. see brady wasnt great to start out at all, he was an average qb with average number and he made himself as great as he is today. and yeah with the new rules he can break 15,000 yds in 3 years. lets see peyton get 2 more superbowls or even as much wins as brady gets. face it brady got all the important stats and most of the less important ones all in favor of him.
your still not getting it and you never will cuz your homer vision glasses are on to tight. Patriots have always had the all around better team until this season. Brady finally led a team that really relied on him, they didnt have that great defense to put him in position to win at the end of games which is quite fitting that Brady choked away the game in the Superbowl.
trust me our record was bad going into the 2001 season and it was mainly bill belichick that got us that superbowl win. and yeah you're right about peyton being a better QB then. see he was monstrous while our offense really relied on the running game. then we lost that defense and Brady stepped the fuck up and while doing so surpassed almost every QB record there is. you average out there wins to losses and Brady is better (even if you do it after the great defense) if you compare the stats and brady's are better (even if you compare after the great defense) so now what? whats the excuse now? just STFU until you have something better to argue about, till then let the grown ups talk sports, the kids table to your left.
this arguement could really go either way... it's fucking stupid to get worked up about it from either side because it's so subjective. both are great quarterbacks.
I've always felt Brady has had a little more help around him than Peyton, in terms of overall talent on the roster, and coaching as well. Therefore, I've always felt Peyton is a little more valuable to his team. With that being said, Brady does have 2 more rings than Peyton... and you can't argue with that
I do think it's dumb to say Brady is just a "system QB." Brady is one of the best quarterbacks of our time, and arguably one of the best ever. He should not be discredited by saying he's nothing more than a product of the system he is in. He's a great QB, period.
With all that being said... fuck Tom Brady and the god damn Patriots... and fuck the tuck rule too. It was a fumble, bitches.
I've always felt Brady has had a little more help around him than Peyton, in terms of overall talent on the roster, and coaching as well. Therefore, I've always felt Peyton is a little more valuable to his team. With that being said, Brady does have 2 more rings than Peyton... and you can't argue with that
I do think it's dumb to say Brady is just a "system QB." Brady is one of the best quarterbacks of our time, and arguably one of the best ever. He should not be discredited by saying he's nothing more than a product of the system he is in. He's a great QB, period.
With all that being said... fuck Tom Brady and the god damn Patriots... and fuck the tuck rule too. It was a fumble, bitches.
i agree with everything but the talent part. peyton has had atleast 1 all-pro reciever and tight end at all times in his career. brady has only had that like twice at best (and he broke all peytons records with it) and for coaching yeah belichick is better but not by much, tony dungy was a very good coach. and i'm not getting worked up at all lol. oh and lets not forget peyton had an amazing RB for a long period of his career aswell. he had one twice.
FOR YOU T-RIP i averaged out Brady's career WITHOUT the "great defense" and compared it to manning's
Tom Brady
Completion % - 65.01
Yards - 4331.1
Touchdowns - 34.6
Interceptions - 10.5
QB Rating - 101.7
Record - 13-3
Playoff record - 7-6
Peyton Manning
Completion % - 64.9
Yards - 4217
Touchdowns - 30.6
Interceptions - 15.2
QB Rating - 94.9
Record - 11-5
Playoff Record - 9-10
The only thing peyton's higher in is Ints so what argument you have now?
FOR YOU T-RIP i averaged out Brady's career WITHOUT the "great defense" and compared it to manning's
Tom Brady
Completion % - 65.01
Yards - 4331.1
Touchdowns - 34.6
Interceptions - 10.5
QB Rating - 101.7
Record - 13-3
Playoff record - 7-6
Peyton Manning
Completion % - 64.9
Yards - 4217
Touchdowns - 30.6
Interceptions - 15.2
QB Rating - 94.9
Record - 11-5
Playoff Record - 9-10
The only thing peyton's higher in is Ints so what argument you have now?