You've said a lot of stupid things on this forum and I've kicked back and never called you on it for the simple fact you're a Niner fan, but saying Manning has "always had a 'sicc' defense" truly shows how little you know about football. I won't even provide evidence because everyone with half a fuckin brain understands Peyton rarely gets help from that defense, and when he does he's won it all. If his defense was anything close to "sicc" he would have 3-4 rings by now. Brady's defenses were "sick," Peyton's have either been at or below average - at best.
As for the O-Line.. Do you bother to watch Tom Brady? When does he ever get hit? His line is just as good and during his championship years it was probably better. Look what happened the one time a team actually put pressure on him - he lost the fuckin Super Bowl.
Peyton Manning does so much more than any other QB it's not even close, but I honestly wouldn't expect you to know or understand what I'm talking about when I say that.
What the fuck are you talking about? Both running games have sucked balls for years. You must be thinking of back in the day when Edge was in Indianapolis, but Peyton has proven to be successful without a good running game for many years.
You're the type of guy that thinks Joseph Addai was tearing shit up in the Super Bowl, not understand that the Saints weren't focused on trying to stop the league's WORST running game, but rather to stop the league's motherfucking MVP and THAT is why Addai was successful. There are strategies and concepts in football that you will never understand.
Did you not see Manning light it up with Austin Collie? Really, who the fuck is Austin Collie? What about Pierre Garcon? These are NOBODIES. The guys Brady was working with are better than these guys, yet Peyton can still get them the fucking ball.
And since you want to default to the old "Brady had no big-name receivers" argument, do you think he's better than Joe Montana? Cuz, you know, Montana had the greatest receiver of all time to throw to, right? He also had John Taylor and Dwight Clark. Does that make Montana any less of a QB?
On top of all that, the guys Brady had were no slouches. They ran routes, got open and fuckin CAUGHT THE BALL. Find a new angle if you want to ride Tom Brady's dick, cuz that one is old and played the fuck out.
Brady is a system QB. Look at what whack ass Matt Cassell was able to do in Bellicheat's system. Their coach has them set up for success. Peyton Manning IS the system in Indianapolis.
Now, let's see what mind-blowing argument you provide in return.. I won't be expecting much. After all, you are the same guy that insists on calling the raiders the "RaidTurds." That says it all.