BETTER QB...AIKMAN OR YOUNG???

[phil]

I'd give the WR/receiving corps to Young though because of Rice, J.T., Brent Jones, and the Niners used their running backs as receivers out of the backfield more than Dallas did.

how old were you when they were playing? are you fucking serious? brent jones? jt? BWAHAHAHAHAAAAA@!!!!!!!!!

you gotta be fucking kidding me.
irvin/harper/novacek/smith/johnston> anything steve young ever had at one time even with rice. rice was better than irvin obviously but besides that aikman could have taken a nap on first and second down and still taken that team to the superbowl. get real.

 

[phil]

WR - 49er's , Jerry Rice shits on Irvin, and John Taylor WRECKS Harper. Harper only has 191 career catches, with 21 touchdowns, and never a season over 1000 yards. Taylor had 347 catches, and 43 touchdowns, plus two 1000 yard seasons. i'll give you that.
HB - Cowboys ,its hard to beat Smith, but Ricky Waters has the best hands of ANY RB ever, seeing the man catch a ball was just plane out pretty his hands where so soft. ricky watters couldnt hold emmit smiths jockstrap. even with his "hands"
TE - 49ers - Brent Jones/ this ones about even.
and overall the 49ers Offense shit on the crack boys. and thats my point. with less.

thats all

 

[MRTHECOSE]

irvin/harper/novacek/smith/johnston> anything steve young ever had at one time even with rice. rice was better than irvin obviously but besides that aikman could have taken a nap on first and second down and still taken that team to the superbowl. get real.

aikman had more weapons consistently over the years. and the team of dallas was better over all but young was the superior qb

 

[fRESH88]

young can scramble but aikman had the arm and accuracy

 

[phil]

aikman had more weapons consistently over the years. and the team of dallas was better over all but young was the superior qb

exactly.

 

[T-Rip]

Young was definitely better but Aikman is still great in his own right

 

[BROWN GUERRERO]

Young for sure.

 

[ALL BOUT CHICKEN]

all i gotta say is fuck steve young.

but i respect that guy. and yes, he is better than aikman.






especially at getting concussions.

 

[Rich]

all i gotta say is fuck steve young.

but i respect that guy. and yes, he is better than aikman.






especially at getting concussions.

Funny you say that cuz Aikman had 10 concussions over his career and LaVar Arrington also ended Aikman's career just like Young's did.

 

[Skizzy Ske]

^maaan, arrington BEFORE he got injured was the shiiiiiiiit. he was a beast at penn state too.

im sure everyone has seen that youtube vid of arrington when he was at penn state, jumped over the o linemen and tackled the RB i think... shit was so raw. i havent seen that vid in a minute.

 

[ALL BOUT CHICKEN]

Funny you say that cuz Aikman had 10 concussions over his career and LaVar Arrington also ended Aikman's career just like Young's did.

i know aikman had hella concussions.

and it wasn't lavar arrington that ended young's career, it was aeneas williams.

 

[Arson]

aikman had more weapons consistently over the years. and the team of dallas was better over all but young was the superior qb

Aikman did not have more weapons, the 49ers offense was not only superior, but way more explosive, the cowboys are lucky they dodged the 49ers in the 1995 play off's, it could have gotten ugly.

 

[KrazeeRDM]

why the fuck ppl make these threads and then dont put a pol with it? the fuck

 

[Rich]

i know aikman had hella concussions.

and it wasn't lavar arrington that ended young's career, it was aeneas williams.

I obviously know Arrington didn't take out Young, hellooooooooooo? I meant that Young and Aikman both got knocked out of football period via concussions.

 

[D'struction]

young can scramble but aikman had the arm and accuracy

pretty much.....aikman just pretty much had to go in and not make mistakes, with all the talent he had around him.
young could create some shit. backyard style. rice was crazy. fuck the 9ers though.

 

[TRAJIK1]

YOUNG WAS THE BETTER QB, AIKMAN WAS DOPE TOO THO

 

[MRTHECOSE]

Aikman did not have more weapons, the 49ers offense was not only superior, but way more explosive, the cowboys are lucky they dodged the 49ers in the 1995 play off's, it could have gotten ugly.

i stand by what i say

 

[Solitary 1]

AIKMAN. IT WOULD HAVE BEEN INTERESTING TO SEE WHAT YOUNG WOULD'VE DONE WITHOUT JERRY RICE. NOT TO SAY AIKMAN DIDN'T HAVE WEAPONS, YOUNG JUST HAD WHAT WAS PROBABY THE BEST OFFENSIVE FOOTBALL PLAYER OF ALL TIME AND IT HEAVILY PADDED ALL HIS NUMBERS, (TD'S, YARDS, QB RATING), YOUNG WAS DOPE, BUT I'VE ALWAYS THOUGHT HE WAS OVERRATED. AIKMAN WAS A BEAST WITH 2 MINUTES LEFT IN A GAME WITH ONLY ONE SHOT TO SCORE.

HE WAS THE BETTER QB.

OH YEAH HE HAS WHAT, 3 RINGS?

 

[T-Dubb]

" YOUNG JUST HAD WHAT WAS PROBABY THE BEST OFFENSIVE FOOTBALL PLAYER OF ALL TIME AND IT HEAVILY PADDED ALL HIS NUMBERS"

Young didnt play with Jim Brown.

both teams were real similar. I would take Young over Aikman. an to the dudes says Aikman was more accurate, doesnt Steve Young have the best qb rating ever?

 

[D'struction]

^^ yup....but like dude said....Superbowl rings