BETTER QB...AIKMAN OR YOUNG???

[Tony]

how old were you when they were playing? are you fucking serious? brent jones? jt? BWAHAHAHAHAAAAA@!!!!!!!!!

you gotta be fucking kidding me.
irvin/harper/novacek/smith/johnston> anything steve young ever had at one time even with rice. rice was better than irvin obviously but besides that aikman could have taken a nap on first and second down and still taken that team to the superbowl. get real.

You damn right I'm serious.... irvin/harper/novacek/smith/johnston couldn't get with rice/taylor/jones/watters/floyd. You get real... Aikman without that offensive line was a sitting duck.

 

[Arson]

People are fucking idiots, when Young won the super bowl in 88-89, he started games, because joe was hurt, in 88 the 49ers where 10-6, if Steve lost one of those games, we would have missed the play off's, NO super bowl, he deserves that shit, football is a team game, Young got 3 super bowls, and 43 rushing touchdowns.

 

[Tony]

43 rushing TD's???? Young is killin' Aikman! It's over now! This comparison has to stop...

 

[Arson]

over 4000 yards rushing.

 

[Tony]

Who said Aikman was more accurate? Young ran the west coast offense... accuracy is a must when running the west coast offense. No mas.... Young wins.

 

[T-Rip]

^^^ you got a good point there, honestly if Young had a great team like Montana did he would easily have more rings. Youngs form was hella good and he was hella accurate, he might not of thrown bullets but he usually got the job done.

 

[Arson]

^^^ you got a good point there, honestly if Young had a great team like Montana did he would easily have more rings. Youngs form was hella good and he was hella accurate, he might not of thrown bullets but he usually got the job done.

Young had just as good of teams as montana, he lacked coaching.

 

[T-Rip]

Not only that, i remember when they use to play Dallas once they got inside like the 30 yard line i could almost always guarantee they would be held to a field goal. Ever since Ricky Waters left they didnt have another good running back until Garrison Hearst came

 

[Arson]

Not only that, i remember when they use to play Dallas once they got inside like the 30 yard line i could almost always guarantee they would be held to a field goal. Ever since Ricky Waters left they didnt have another good running back until Garrison Hearst came

uhh, they beat the living fuck outta dallas with out Steve Young, and Ricky Watters, Floyd, or Brent Jones in 95. Being 14 point underdogs, It was the worst beating the 92-95 cowboy dynasty ever took.

 

[PoLLo LoC831]

im a niners fan and i should go wit young but the tru is aikman got three rings and young only got one! so dat says it all but young was still a bad ass QB he just lost too many play offs game to the cowboys 92 93 to start off wit

 

[Arson]

im a niners fan and i should go wit young but the tru is aikman got three rings and young only got one! so dat says it all but young was still a bad ass QB he just lost too many play offs game to the cowboys 92 93 to start off wit

Young has 3 rings.

 

[Tony]

im a niners fan and i should go wit young but the tru is aikman got three rings and young only got one! so dat says it all but young was still a bad ass QB he just lost too many play offs game to the cowboys 92 93 to start off wit

The Niners lost those playoff games to the Cowboys not Young. Young played good in those games... the Niners D couldn't stop Emmitt Smith.

So Emmitt Smith was a better running back than Barry Sanders because he got three rings and Barry got none? It's take a whole team to win a championship not one guy.

 

[PoLLo LoC831]

Young has 3 rings.

yeah he does but you know what i'm talkin about i aint takin anything away from young i like da guy he was one of da best qb in dat time, but he only got the niners to one super bowl in da 90's i would of loved more, but when it came down to it aikman went to the super bowl more times N got more rings.

 

[Arson]

The Niners lost those playoff games to the Cowboys not Young. Young played good in those games... the Niners D couldn't stop Emmitt Smith.

So Emmitt Smith was a better running back than Barry Sanders because he got three rings and Barry got none? It's take a whole team to win a championship not one guy.

The Cowboys played keep away from the 49ers potent offense with there sound running game, but the 1992 game should have went different, there was some VERY VERY terrible calls.

 

[MRTHECOSE]

super bowl championships dont = greatness or better qb
marino/kelly= no rings
dilfer/ brad johnson= rings

 

[Tony]

Good point!^^^^

 

[PoLLo LoC831]

yup it is a good point, but in this game of the NFL every qb dream is to get to the Super Bowl and if theres no ring, and u cant win a super bowl it doesnt mean anything watch (In Their Own Words) Steve Young he says it him self

 

[Arson]

Steve Young's Awards
7x Pro Bowl selection (1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998)
7x All-Pro selection (1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998)
3x Super Bowl champion (XXIII, XXIV, XXIX)
Super Bowl XXIX MVP
2x NFL MVP (1992, 1994)
2x PFWA NFL MVP (1992, 1994)
2x NEA NFL MVP (1992, 1994)
1992 NFL Offensive Player of the Year
2x UPI NFC Player of the Year (1992, 1994)
2x Bert Bell Award (1992, 1994)
1983 Davey O'Brien Award

Troy Aikmans Awards
6x Pro Bowl selection (1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996)
3x All-Pro selection (1993, 1994, 1995)
3x Super Bowl champion (XXVII, XXVIII, XXX)
Super Bowl XXVII MVP
1997 Walter Payton Man of the Year
1988 Davey O'Brien Award

 

[Arson]

Both where number 1 overall picks in there respective drafts.

 

[MRTHECOSE]

yup it is a good point, but in this game of the NFL every qb dream is to get to the Super Bowl and if theres no ring, and u cant win a super bowl it doesnt mean anything watch (In Their Own Words) Steve Young he says it him self

u based your argument on who is better by stating aikman has more rings wich means he is better.. so what u saying now??