Nah I saw it as the Seattle game being his worst, which wasn't surprising since we didn't have our first team offense on the field the entire preseason, than I thought he had a great game vs the Saints, even with the first snap of the game and delanie fumble, @ Atlanta he started hot finished cold, had a great game vs Philly, and did fine vs the Raiders. Hes clearly better than David Carr but its 9ers first and Troys legs and arm make our weapons more visible on Sunday so it is what it is. My point is I thought Smith got fucked out of a win vs the Saints, Frank lost two fumbles vs Philly, I think Alex woulda won the Carolina game, and was/is capable of beating the donks and the rams. The real test for Troy is @ Arizona, we need a road win bad