I use to mess with this Angelina Jolie type girl (a bit more thick..real nice). And I asked her one night.
"What do you see in me?"
She said she didn't like skinny or muscle dudes. She loved big dudes because big dudes reminded her of a big teddy bears. And I've had plenty of top notches that felt that way. And of course I had the skinny insecure haters looking and asking, "How, did he pull that?"
Don't let this confuse you though, I've had em' all shapes and sizes. I don't discriminate (yet, there are areas I won't go).