Ask the experts: Who has more talent, the Raiders or 49ers?

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
Rich

Rich

Sicc OG
#22
Jul 22, 2003
6,700
0
0
44
#22
QB = 49ers (Garcia is good but you can only throw to Zach Miller so many times and his arm aint that strong)
RB = 49ers (Gore shits on any Raider RB)
WR = 49ers (Bruce, Morgan, Jason Hill, and now Crabtree > Raiders receivers)
TE = Raiders (Zach Miller > Vernon Davis)
OL = 49ers
DL = Raiders (49ers don't even have a fuckin d-line)
LB = 49ers (Willis + Spikes > Raiders LBs)
CB = Raiders
S = Raiders
K = 49ers (Although I liked it when Kiffin went for that 70 yard fg with Janikowski)
P = Raiders (Andy Lee is good but he dropped off last season)
Coaching = 49ers
Owner = 49ers :lick:
 
Chree

Chree

Medicated
#24
Dec 7, 2005
32,404
13,935
113
40
#24
radiostationrep said:
lmao.you are one blind fan. i'm not mad at you though.
Click to expand...
How So? heres how it breaks down

QB = Raiders Reason: Depth, When JR sees the bench, the Raiders have a former pro bowler to lead

RB = 49ers Reason: Gore is a probowler, Neal has paved the way for LT and Mcgahee, but Norris Led Gore to a franchise rushing record. DMAC is about as unproven as coffee is and Michael Robinson has proven to be a pro bowl caliber special teamer.

WR = 49ers Reason: deepest WR Core in recent memory, Javon hasnt done shit in years, Isaac Bruce still plays at a high level.

TE = 49ers Reason: Depth, Vernon Davis may not be the best catcher, but hes a great blocker, and Delanie Walker contributes as a trick kick Returner, and as a former WR, he has very good hands, Bear Pascoe was considered the best blocking TE in the draft, and he can catch as well.

OL = 49ers Reason: Staley has shown he is on the way to becoming a pro bowl tackle, and Heitmann is one of the best, Rachal showed to be a beast in his playing time, Marvel Smith is a pro bowler when healthy, Baas is playing well and is in a contract year.

DL = Raiders Reason: 49ers run a 3-4 and have no NT, that pretty much makes the rest of the guys useless....

LB = 49ers Reason: Willis and Spikes are pro bowl caliber talents, Manny Lawson is returning for his 2nd year back from his knee injury ala julian peterson, and should have a breakout year, Parys Haralson had 8 sacks last year and shown he can rush the passer

CB = Raiders Reason: Harris out for year, leaves Clements and either Bly or Brown.

S = Draw a buncha unproven players here except michael lewis
K = Draw

P = Draw
Coaching = 49ers Reason: Cable has had no success in the nfl or college ranks as a HC
 
radiostationrep

radiostationrep

Sicc OG
#25
Dec 2, 2006
6,161
44
0
#25
Rich said:
WORSE THAN THE 9ERS THATS ALL THAT MATTERS HERE!!!!!!!! hahaha
Click to expand...
if your talking records, i guess you are right. but the result is the same. a few more wins has costed me some money but means nothing when you dont win it all. i guess you could look forward to next year but that is short-lived in the NFL. ask the jaguars, patriots, cowboys, etc...............
 
radiostationrep

radiostationrep

Sicc OG
#26
Dec 2, 2006
6,161
44
0
#26
Chree said:
How So? heres how it breaks down

QB = Raiders Reason: Depth, When JR sees the bench, the Raiders have a former pro bowler to lead

RB = 49ers Reason: Gore is a probowler, Neal has paved the way for LT and Mcgahee, but Norris Led Gore to a franchise rushing record. DMAC is about as unproven as coffee is and Michael Robinson has proven to be a pro bowl caliber special teamer.

WR = 49ers Reason: deepest WR Core in recent memory, Javon hasnt done shit in years, Isaac Bruce still plays at a high level.

TE = 49ers Reason: Depth, Vernon Davis may not be the best catcher, but hes a great blocker, and Delanie Walker contributes as a trick kick Returner, and as a former WR, he has very good hands, Bear Pascoe was considered the best blocking TE in the draft, and he can catch as well.

OL = 49ers Reason: Staley has shown he is on the way to becoming a pro bowl tackle, and Heitmann is one of the best, Rachal showed to be a beast in his playing time, Marvel Smith is a pro bowler when healthy, Baas is playing well and is in a contract year.

DL = Raiders Reason: 49ers run a 3-4 and have no NT, that pretty much makes the rest of the guys useless....

LB = 49ers Reason: Willis and Spikes are pro bowl caliber talents, Manny Lawson is returning for his 2nd year back from his knee injury ala julian peterson, and should have a breakout year, Parys Haralson had 8 sacks last year and shown he can rush the passer

CB = Raiders Reason: Harris out for year, leaves Clements and either Bly or Brown.

S = Draw a buncha unproven players here except michael lewis
K = Draw

P = Draw
Coaching = 49ers Reason: Cable has had no success in the nfl or college ranks as a HC
Click to expand...
LOL. you smoking some o.g. tonight?
 
Chree

Chree

Medicated
#27
Dec 7, 2005
32,404
13,935
113
40
#27
instead of wise cracking, why not counter with a argument with valid points?


btw its some of this super silver haze shit, its good lolll
 
radiostationrep

radiostationrep

Sicc OG
#28
Dec 2, 2006
6,161
44
0
#28
an argument is useless because you are blinded by your love for the niners. your opinion is very biased. i'm not a hater and can give a team credit where it is due. even if it is the niners or the giants.
 
Chree

Chree

Medicated
#29
Dec 7, 2005
32,404
13,935
113
40
#29
radiostationrep said:
an argument is useless because you are blinded by your love for the niners. your opinion is very biased. i'm not a hater and can give a team credit where it is due. even if it is the niners or the giants.
Click to expand...
I gave credit...


QB = Raiders Reason: Depth, When JR sees the bench, the Raiders have a former pro bowler to lead

DL = Raiders Reason: 49ers run a 3-4 and have no NT, that pretty much makes the rest of the guys useless....


CB = Raiders Reason: Harris out for year, leaves Clements and either Bly or Brown.

see. Im just sayin, instead of critiquing, why not give your insight on position battles?
 
Chree

Chree

Medicated
#36
Dec 7, 2005
32,404
13,935
113
40
#36
and for coondog fuck the vikings
and for 90sbayplayer fuck the rams
and for gay Z boss Fuck the tards


but yeah come on radiorep, not trynna take my challenge?


oh and the niner raider preseason game is on my bday this year, imma get fucked up there, we should have like a sicc tailgate
 
savage

savage

OG
#37
Feb 14, 2004
16,667
4,746
113
42
#37
& fuck the raiders & fuck the 9ers & fuck the cardinals & fuck the rams & A BIG FUCK YOU TO THE STEELERS.

haha!
 
radiostationrep

radiostationrep

Sicc OG
#38
Dec 2, 2006
6,161
44
0
#38
Chree said:
and for coondog fuck the vikings
and for 90sbayplayer fuck the rams
and for gay Z boss Fuck the tards


but yeah come on radiorep, not trynna take my challenge?


oh and the niner raider preseason game is on my bday this year, imma get fucked up there, we should have like a sicc tailgate
Click to expand...
you saying the punters are a draw pretty much summed it up. no need to argue this point.

i'll never go to a game at candlestick again. the last game i went to there was when we beat you guys in o.t. i couldnt get out the parking lot for 3 hours. literally didnt even move.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom