What!!!!!...I'm not hatin' on number one, it certainly has some nice features such as angle and whatnot, however, it's not a vector!! The tranferablity of (1) will be a huge let down if trying to showcase it beyond the Net. What about t-shirts, banners, car wrap. I also think that (1) is gathering more votes because of how its showcased (on a white background). Visually, it pops more....however, judging by straight artistic skill and head to head complexity, #2 takes it with NO THOUGHT!
(Note: Never make a logo for a client without presenting it in vector...you not only limit the client but the chance to aquire future work from that client.)