Part One!!! Quarterbacks!!

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
T

T-Dubb

Sicc OG
#3
Apr 25, 2002
1,617
30
48
#3
better re open that case an put a real number 1 in there................JOHN ELWAY

Marino was a better pure passer, but Elway was a better qb
 
TRAGIC LOSSES

TRAGIC LOSSES

Sicc OG
#10
Apr 25, 2002
3,461
542
0
50
#10
I WILL BREAK DOWN MOST OF THE CHOICES SO FAR.....

MARINO-HOLDS MOST STAT RECORDS FOR QB'S-NEVER HAD A RUNNING GAME IN HIS CAREER-HAD INFERIOR OVERALL TEAMS COMPARED TO THE OTHERS LISTED....NEVER WON SUPERBOWL,BUT NEVER HAD A SUPERBOWL TEAM AROUND HIM...

ELWAY-TOP 10 QB IN MY BOOK-HAD SEVERAL 1000 YD RUNNERS IN CAREER-HAD 3 AMIGOS AND SHARPE-FINALLY WON THE BIG ONE......I MEAN TEREL DAVIS WON IT......MOST 4TH QUARTER COMEBACKS IN HISTORY(HAD TO LET HIS TEAM GET BEHIND A LOT TO DO THIS THOUGH)

MONTANA-ALWAYS HAD A GREAT TEAM AROUND HIM-HAD RICE-TAYLOR-CRAIG......HAD A TOP DEFENSE-DID ENOUGH TO WIN NOTHING MORE-WHEN HE WENT TO KC,HE WASN'T SHIT BECAUSE HE HAD A TEAM SIMILIAR TO THOSE MARINO HAD.....A TOP 5 QB

STAUBACH-NEVER SAW PLAY....BUT CONSIDERED BY MOST EXPERTS TO BE A TOP 10 QB

BRADSHAW-HAD GREAT TEAMS AROUND HIM.....STEEL CURTAIN...WASN'T VERY ACCUATE....TOP 20 QB

UNITAS-TOP 3 QB...SAW TAPES OF HIM PLAYIN......STATISTICALLY A GREAT QB.....A REAL LEADER AND ATHLETE....

MY HONEST OPINIONS.....
 
The Duke of Earl

The Duke of Earl

Sicc OG
#11
Apr 25, 2002
10,848
199
0
40
#11
STEVE YOUNG WAS THE SHIT , IMMA A RAIDER BUT I GOTTA ADMIT STEVE YOUNG CARRYED THE NINERS AT TIMES , ATHELETICALLY HE WAS A POOR MANS MICHAEL VICK , AT TIMES HE WAS THERE RUNNING AND PASSING GAME .
 
K

KINGCZAR

Sicc OG
#12
May 19, 2002
4,860
0
0
www.cdbaby.com
#12
Haha T-Dubb Naw , like I said there aint no clear cut QB, and Staubach did start a few things, and he was tight..

We will see what RB & WR I pick though!

After a few more choices, we will declare a winner and move to the next category!
 
MR. CLEEN

MR. CLEEN

CEO/Producer of E&K Music Group
#14
Apr 25, 2002
2,152
77
0
52
#14
JOE IS THE MAN

Tragic Losses you must be stupid... Dan Marino only had so many yardsbecause he had no choice but to throw it... Joe montana won a super bowl before Jerry Rice and Roger Craig even joined the team. he started the Niner dynasty. Steve Young has better stats but could never get the Niners to the Bowl so fuck stats. Oh yeah who handed Marino his loss in his one and only shot at the BOWL... JOE. The best pocket passer in the game. He made every pass look pretty, and look easy. Clearly the Jordan of Football. Joe almost took KC to the Bowl in his first year there at almost 40... John Elway one of the best in the game didn't even win one until he got Terrell Davis, who would have been one of the best back of all time if he hadn't got hurt... Marino was good, but not great. Stats don't mean nuthin with out the ring. Who wouldn't have those type of stats if they threw the ball as muchas him. Perfect example, Warren Moon. All he did was throw the ball, and never won or made it to the bowl, but his passing stats looked lovely.... Brett Favre is better, I'd even say Kurt Warner is better(Closest will get to another Joe). My favorites were Dan Fouts, Elway, Favre(Even he was a niner killer), Doug Williams(Only black qb to win the Super Bowl), Warren Moon, Jim Kelly(Went to the Bowl 4 times in a row, even though they lost which wasn't all his fault) I could name more. If we goin off stats Marino is in there but if we goin off mastership of the position, and reinventing the position Joe is hands down the King...
 
B

BAMMER

Siccness Gray Hair
#17
Apr 25, 2002
5,828
479
83
48
Auburn Wa
www.dawgman.com
#17
Re: JOE IS THE MAN

MR. CLEEN said:
Tragic Losses you must be stupid... Dan Marino only had so many yardsbecause he had no choice but to throw it... Joe montana won a super bowl before Jerry Rice and Roger Craig even joined the team. he started the Niner dynasty.

IS IT DAN'S FAULT?LOL...DOES BARKLEY AND MALONE SUCK?"YOU"SOUND STUPID....DO THE NAMES RUSS FRANCIS,RONNIE LOTT,KEENA TURNER,MATT MILLEN,DWIGHT CLARK RING A BELL???HE ALWAYS HAD GOOD TEAMS AROUND HIM...GIMME A BREAK

"Steve Young has better stats but could never get the Niners to the Bowl so fuck stats." MONTANA BEAT THE CHARGERS IN WHAT....1995?

"JOE. He made every pass look pretty, and look easy". AH,SOME GUY NAME JERRY RICE WAS ON THE RECIEVING END OF THOSE

"John Elway one of the best in the game didn't even win one until he got Terrell Davis, who would have been one of the best back of all time if he hadn't got hurt..." ELWAY TOOK 3 AVERAGE TEAMS THERE WITHOUT A RUNNING GAME,AND THE THREE AMIGOS,WHO WERE AVERAGE RECIEVERS AT BEST.TERREL WAS GOOD..INDEED

"Marino was good, but not great".MARINO WAS GREAT,WHAT ARE YOU SMOKIN?DUPER AND CLAYTON WERE GOOD,BUT HE WON WITH ZERO RUNNING GAME.....HOW DOES THAT TAKE AWAY HIM BEING A GREAT QUARTERBACK?WE'RE NOT BASING THIS ON THE OTHER 10 PLAYERS WHO ARE ON THE FIELD WITH HIM?OR ARE WE

Stats don't mean nuthin with out the ring. THIS POST DID'NT READ THAT WAY?IS TRENT DILFER BETTER THAN MARINO

I'd even say Kurt Warner is better(Closest will get to another Joe). SCHEME...LOOK AT THERE BACKUP RIGHT NOW,AND HE DOES'NT THROW 5 PICKS A GAME LIKE WARNER.....LOL@ THAT COMMENT

Doug Williams AKA TIMMY SMITH(won the Super Bowl),

If we goin off stats Marino is in there ... THATS A BIG PART OF IT,FOR DAMN SURE
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom