NFL CBOY

[CHAPO GUZMAN]

Yall might think im crazy...I know its still early but I have two players in mind, right here in the Bay.. Carson Palmer or Alex Smith.. Palmer because he's getting it done with different receivers given the Raiders injuries, and Alex Smith has stunk in SF for 6 years up until now, most of it not his fault due to coaching changes every season.. who can win under those kind of changes?

Who do you nominate??

 

[Count_Slapula]

Everything you just described:

It happens in the NFL all the time..

 

[RAS 925]

Palmer came off tha couch at mid-season with a brand new team and is performing like a SOLID VET QB. should... told yal that 3 int game was obviously a fluke.. he was forced into tha fire after 3 days of being on tha team.. now that he's playing week in and week out he's getting better and better.. making throws JC can never even dream about throwing.. but with all that said.. Carson came in wayyy to late to even be considered for CBOY

 

[RAS 925]

and if I recall Palmer had put up decent #s ona slumping cinci squad last year.. even tho his INT rate was high.. but supposibly he was playing thru injury.. so I wouldn't really consider him a come back player

 

[Defy]

I nominate pookie from 73rd ave in deep east oakland for DBOY