nba rookie of the year

[young scrillen]

lebron or anthony

i'm giong wit carmello

 

[LMD1510]

Carmelo

 

[MB3]

they both would deserve it like Hill and Kidd did a while ago

 

[T-Dubb]

yea they both deserve it...........but Mello has got the nuggets respectable again, an the cavs still suck.........so Mello

 

[cartoon]

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Yea well Anthony has a better team around him. Close call though I think Ill wait till the season ends to make up my mind.

 

[SLOWPOKE]

Mello has got the nuggets respectable again, an the cavs still suck.........so Mello

 

[MrFedEx503]

Easy of course is Mello all u have to do is look how the two teams are doin. Denver is the biggest surprize in the NBA this year

 

[BornSin]

Easy of course is Mello all u have to do is look how the two teams are doin. Denver is the biggest surprize in the NBA this year

Denver is playing some nice ball right now but the biggest suprise in the NBA this year has to be Memphis.....And Mello is a part of the reason Denver is doing so well but it is also, Andre Miller, Camby, Voshon, Nene etc......

James doesnt have the support that Mello has....plus Lebrons numbers are a little better.....my vote goes to James....

 

[Benzo]

if the voting were for Most Valuable Rookie to his team then it would go to Mello fo sho.

Rookie of the Year will be LEBRON JAMES,

 

[onlyonesmoke]

anthony is going to take it. he has turned denver around and maybe playoff bound..

 

[bayGIANTS]

the most important thing in sports is winning and carmelo has won a lot more.

 

[TormentedN9NE]

melo also has more help, its not just him turning the team around. id say lebron deserves it

 

[CZAR]

Mello has no shot at ROY!! Wade is better than Mello!! James has that sown up mane!! GOT EM!!

 

[AC Transit]

Lebron

even though Melo has led them back to respectability, look at his supporting cast. Lebron is basically his whole team and he's carried them all year.

 

[DuckSauce]

dwayne wade is better than both of them.

 

[CZAR]

Yo smokin some potenent shit duck!! James will be thee best player in the NBA real soon!! He is the next great thing!! Wade is better than Mello, but he wont come close to James mane!! GOT EM!!

 

[T-Dubb]

if Lebron has such a weaker cast shouldnt his numbers be alot better then lest than a point in per game??????

an Czar you are crazy if you think Wade is better then Mello.......thats just blatant hatred for Carmello


http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/lebron/line?compId=1975

 

[AC Transit]

If you have a weak cast, other teams can key on you more - they don't have to worry about the other players hurting them as much. Who do you want shooting the outside J on the draw and dish? Voshon Lenard or Eric Williams?

 

[Blackjack 1577]

Carmelo is tha real rookie of tha year, but James will probably win it based on his popularity truth be told.

And you trippin if you think James is better than Mello

 

[CZAR]

Ok black u already know the deal!! I just wanna hear what u have to say in 1-2 years when James is the ambassador of the league and establish himself as the best player!! mello is coo but wont be close!! And dubb me sayin Wade is better than Mello aint hatred!! Yes u can argue it but I like his game better but its close though!! But regardless neither can fuck with James and James will distance himself from them in 1-2 years!! GOT EM!!