If Tim tebow wins another heisman and another championship....

[TRAGIC LOSSES]

is it safe to say hes the best college qb of all time??

edit: if he isnt who is ??

 

[killahoe666]

absolutely not

 

[King Spadez]

Maybe the best shotgun formation QB of all time.

 

[thascary1]

between plunkett, elway, marino, montana, frazier, wuerfel, detmer, manning.....HELL NO!

 

[2-0-Sixx]

DELETE THREAD IMMEDIATELY

 

[Fucky McFuckerson]

A great leader? Absolutely. Best college QB? FUCK no.

 

[YOUNG DEMON]

ANOTHER HEISMAN CURSE FOR TEBOW. IF HE WINS THE HEISMAN THEN THE GATORS ARE NOT GONNA WIN THE TITLE. JUST LIKE THE LAST THREE PLAYERS WHO WON A HEISMAN, BUT THE TEAM NEVER WON A BOWL GAME.

 

[Supa SAV'D OUTT]

is it safe to say hes the best college qb of all time??

edit: if he isnt who is ??

THATS A HARD ONE I WOULD SAY HE'S ONE OF THE BEST COMPETETORS TO EVER PLAY CFB. BUT HE AINT NOWHERE ON A CHARLIE WARDs, ANDRE WARD, PEYTON MANNING, MATT LEINART, TY DETMER, STEVE YOUNG, DAN MARINO, JOE MONTANA AND EVEN RYAN LEAF(HE WAS A BEAST AT WSU)

 

[Supa SAV'D OUTT]

LOL AT TEBOW NOT EVEN BEING PREDICTED TO BE A QB IN THE NFL, TODD McSHAY WAS EVEN SAYIN HE COULD BE A TE IF HE CAN CATCH

 

[REdRUM]

No, not at all.

One of the best all-around talents? Possibly, based solely on the fact that he's a QB running all over defenses, and his improvement and maturity at that position. He'll easily be one of the SEC's best players, judged by the numbers he's put up, including the first ever 20/20 season.

Best QB?

From a Tebow fan, that's a laugh. I'm not that dillusional...

BUT...

...what I will gather from (IF) he wins another championship, is that the spread works, the option works, and a big, physical QB works in college football.

 

[CZAR]

Not even close!! Got Em!!

 

[MaKaVeLi_420]

LOL@Got Em!! you kill me czar

 

[TRAGIC LOSSES]

THATS A HARD ONE I WOULD SAY HE'S ONE OF THE BEST COMPETETORS TO EVER PLAY CFB. BUT HE AINT NOWHERE ON A CHARLIE WARDs, ANDRE WARD, PEYTON MANNING, MATT LEINART, TY DETMER, STEVE YOUNG, DAN MARINO, JOE MONTANA AND EVEN RYAN LEAF(HE WAS A BEAST AT WSU)

most of those guys didnt accomplish much in college...most of them couldnt win the big game(manning)...i dont see how you guys can put them over tebow

 

[REdRUM]

College numbers is what we're talking about, and that's what he should be measured by. I don't think he's the greatest player of all time, but I don't discredit all that he's done, either.

 

[thascary1]

most of those guys didnt accomplish much in college...most of them couldnt win the big game(manning)...i dont see how you guys can put them over tebow

get the fuck outta here! Manning lost 5 games in 4 years! Detmer young marino some of the best college qb's EVER!!!

 

[MooreBlock530]

the vols did good when Manning was at the helms....but hes biggest knock up untill the sb win was manning couldnt win "the big one"......

 

[thascary1]

the vols did good when Manning was at the helms....but hes biggest knock up untill the sb win was manning couldnt win "the big one"......

i dont know if this was at me or tragic loses because I agree...to only lose 5 games in 4 years is outstanding....yet he says he didnt accomplish anything

 

[Fucky McFuckerson]

Tebow just won the Maxwell for the second year in a row.