Don't get me wrong I was pulling for Walters too but he stunk. He made a few good throws but his rating was 18.4. He fumbled 3 times losing one of them, threw 3 INT's, got his receivers damn near killed (Whitted and Moss), and he overthrew a wide open Moss in the end zone. I would still start Brooks if he is healthy and the playoffs were on the line. Once the playoffs are out of reach, I'd sit Brooks and start Walter. Brooks has a better chance of getting the Raiders to the playoffs this year than Walter does.