You call his 2nd season a good one? He threw 16 td's and 16 int's and didn't even reach 60% completion. Yes it was his best season, but I would say it was average at best.
Why wouldnt it be called a good season? By good, i mean good for him, especially with the lack of talent around him....
If he cant do shit this year, hes done, he has 3 legit Wrs, 1 of the Best OCs in the league, a good 1-2 punch @ RB, 2 good tight ends (Delanie Walker is hella underrated, i think Solitary said he liked him alot before too?)
Last year, was fucked for him, really he played 3 games before getting hurt, and went 2-1, and had that bad call in week 3, with VD that turned the game around, you cant really judge a players playing when they have an injury that greatly affects performance, and are playing with it....
Escobar nailed it right on the head too, Frank Gore with the broken hand, and his severe ankle injury made things much harder too...