A poll to end the argument vick or ???

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.

pick 1


  • Total voters
    25
Apr 25, 2002
9,595
5
38
#22
Peyton Manning.

Followed closely by Joe Montana and Steve Young.


phil said:
montana young had stellar teammates and coaching
brady and manning have stellar teammates and coaching

notice theres about 10 superbowls between just those 4 teams.
There would only be 3 teams since Montana and Young were both 49ers.
 

phil

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
7,311
27
0
116
#24
davidsaoc said:
Vick will NEVER win the Super Bowl!!! Mark my words.
and if thats true then he will be in good company with dan marino, dan fouts, jim kelly warren moon.

they all must take a backseat to guys like trent dilfer brad johnson and jim mcmahon right? they all have super bowl rings so what was it you were saying again? some of you kids forget theres 21 other players on the field deciding if a team wins or loses.
 

phil

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
7,311
27
0
116
#29
yeah we're both right fatal, take it easy.

honestly has there been a qb thats had more expected of him with less to work with?

everybody compares vick to brady and manning when new england and indy have done everything possible to ensure their success. how long did indy's defense get ignored to make sure peyton had a stout oline and dependable wrs??? dont forget that even with all that help he didnt take his team to super bowl glory until the complete team came together. too much blame and too much praise gets put on qbs. vick is expected to win despite 3rd tier receivers and a puny offensive line.