SHOULD STEVE YOUNG REALLY BE IN THE H.O.F.?

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
Nov 1, 2004
2,946
78
48
39
#21
Old Niner games were hella fun to watch.
The Cowboys/Niner playoff games every year.. that was some good football.
Steve Young will be in the Hall of Fame.
 

corinthian

Just Win Baby!!!
Feb 23, 2006
5,704
1,257
113
41
3rd ID
#30
yes, and so should plunkett. the plunk led his team to 2 super bowls. the 1980 team was the first wildcard team to win a super bowl. he was the first minority qb to win a super bowl and the only hispanic to win super bowl mvp. one of only four players that won the heisman and a super bowl mvp. makes no sense that he ain't in the hall already.
 

Cut-Throat

Bob Pimp MOBBEN!!!
Apr 25, 2002
7,033
29,861
0
43
#31
Plunkett is in the same boat as Hostetler, Rypien, Dilfer, etc.. when it comes to super bowl winners... he has more picks than td's and 67 career qb rating... Steve Young has better than a 2:1 td/int ratio and and 97 career qb rating... i give plunkett props for winnin a couple bowls and comin off the bench in both seasons to do it, but he aint HOF material...
 

DubbC415

Mickey Fallon
Sep 10, 2002
22,620
6,984
0
37
Tomato Alley
#32
Steve Young also has the best qb rating for a career, and broke his own record several times for it in a season. also has over 4,000 rushing yards, the most for any qb ever.
 

corinthian

Just Win Baby!!!
Feb 23, 2006
5,704
1,257
113
41
3rd ID
#33
you'd have a point if he only won it once, but he won two super bowls. or maybe if he didn't win the super bowl mvp. or make history in several different ways. get the fuck outta here, comparing him to lames like dilfer. you just don't think he should be in 'cause he's a Raider.
 

Cut-Throat

Bob Pimp MOBBEN!!!
Apr 25, 2002
7,033
29,861
0
43
#35
he was a niner too... i dont think Roger Craig is HOF material, and a lot of people do... the Hall is for the best of the best, not guys who had a couple great years...