Looks like Proof was defending himself, new witness says what really happened

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.

Y-S

Sicc OG
Dec 10, 2005
3,765
0
0
#1
A source exclusive to SOHH.com has revealed that the argument that resulted in the death of D12 member Proof was initiated by the other victim in the shootout over a "King of Detroit" argument.

As SOHH previously reported, Proof and Keith Bender got into a heated exchange at Triple C's nightclub early Tuesday morning (April 11) which lead to Proof pistol-whipping and shooting Bender. Proof was then gunned down by Bender's cousin as he stood over Bender.

"[Bender] started an argument with Proof, knowing who he was," the source told SOHH. "Proof told him he didn't want to hear any bullshit and that he was 'King of Detroit' and stuck his hands in [Bender's] face.

"The guy then pulled out his gun and then Proof pulled his out and shot -- hitting the guy," the source added. "The guy's cousin who is a bouncer at the club then shot Proof. They grabbed up the gun from the guy Proof shot and fled."

According to the Wayne County Medical Examiner's Office, Proof was shot three times in the head and the chest. He was pronounced dead on arrival at St. John Conner Creek Village in Detroit. Bender is currently in St. Johns Hospital and Medical Center in critical condition.

On Wednesday afternoon (April 12), Mario Etheridge, a 28 year-old bouncer at the Triple C's nightclub, turned himself in to Detroit Police accompanied by his attorney Randall Upshaw. Upon arrest, he revealed he was Bender's cousin.

Etheridge is still in custody and authorities are continuing to investigate whether he should face charges in the shooting, which Detroit Police said, might have been in self-defense. But SOHH.com sources say Etheridge surrendered out of self-preservation.

"The guy turned himself in out of fear he was going to get got at by Proof's people," said the source. "Proof frequented the place and there is of course no way the bouncer or anyone else in the club didn't know who he was,"

Proof's untimely death continues to overwhelm his fans and peers in the music industry.

Today, Royce Da 5'9" expressed his feelings regarding the unfortunate passing of Proof in a statement.

"I am deeply saddened by the murder of someone I called a good friend. I've known Proof for over nine years and will always remember him for the joy and life that he brought into every room he entered. We first met at Detroit's Hip Hop Shop where Proof was hosting open mics and was considered by most to be Detroit's freestyle king. Even then you could tell there was something special about him."

"Some people might be familiar with a well-publicized beef that Proof and I had a couple of years ago," Royce added via the statement. "Thankfully though, we had not only resolved our conflict, but we also restored our friendship. Back in December, we went overseas together for a few spot dates in Europe where we had a chance to catch up on 'the good ole days.' We both laughed at how we sometimes forget how far we've come, until you look out of your hotel window and see London's Big Ben or Paris's EiffelTower. On that tour we had a chance to visit cities we never even knew existed. Not bad for two kids from Detroit, huh."

"His death is such a loss for the hip hop community, and especially for the city of Detroit. I hope that he will be remembered for the talented artist and great person that he was, and not the tragedy that he fell victim to. My thoughts and prayers go out to his entire family, friends, and anyone that was ever touched by him."


SOURCE: http://sohh.com/articles/article.php/8747
 
Jun 28, 2005
234
0
0
#2
yea i heard about this, i didnt think proof would just shoot someone for no reason, i mean if someone pulls out a gun what do u think their gonna do with it?shoot so he had to get his out before he would get killed, whether bender was gonna shoot or not proof doesnt know what he thinks so for all proof knew he would have had to shoot him or get shot, RIP Proof
 
Sep 12, 2004
1,994
34
0
www.myspace.com
#7
AINT NOTHIN STUPID ABOUT IT NIGGA... YOU ACT LIKE YOU AINT NEVER HAD BEEF DROPPED IN YOUR LAP.. A NIGGA COME WOOFIN AT YOU WHILE YOU CHILLIN AND HE TALKIN ALL THIS AND THAT.. THEN PULL STEEL ON YOU. WHAT YOU GON DO NIGGA? PROOF HANDLED HIS AND THATS WHY THIS NIGGA COUSIN HAD TO JUMP IN AND HELP HIM OUT.. YOU CANT TALK SHIT ON PROOF FOR HOLDIN HIS SHIT DOWN. R.I.P. KING PROOF AKA DERTY HARRY.. LIVEST NIGGA FROM THA DOZEN
 
Jul 1, 2002
834
2
0
41
#8
nigga i had beef in my lap neva had 2 pull a heata tho, i kno niggas that had 2 do that or had that done on them, and u kno wut i call tha nigga that pulls a heata out... A PUSSY
 
Apr 25, 2002
757
0
0
42
#9
Bluntz2dadome said:
nigga i had beef in my lap neva had 2 pull a heata tho, i kno niggas that had 2 do that or had that done on them, and u kno wut i call tha nigga that pulls a heata out... A PUSSY
well if he got a heater pulled on him 1st......i would have done the same thing....someone pull a heater on u and u got one what u gonna do? just sit there and be like u aint gone shoot me dogg.....yea right.....i dont trust niggas like that......
 
Jun 24, 2005
11,754
460
83
40
www.MYSPACE.COM
#14
synical dj said:
AINT NOTHIN STUPID ABOUT IT NIGGA... YOU ACT LIKE YOU AINT NEVER HAD BEEF DROPPED IN YOUR LAP.. A NIGGA COME WOOFIN AT YOU WHILE YOU CHILLIN AND HE TALKIN ALL THIS AND THAT.. THEN PULL STEEL ON YOU. WHAT YOU GON DO NIGGA? PROOF HANDLED HIS AND THATS WHY THIS NIGGA COUSIN HAD TO JUMP IN AND HELP HIM OUT.. YOU CANT TALK SHIT ON PROOF FOR HOLDIN HIS SHIT DOWN. R.I.P. KING PROOF AKA DERTY HARRY.. LIVEST NIGGA FROM THA DOZEN
co-sign